Advertising disclosure: EarlyCardIndex is a participant in the eBay Partner Network. Links to eBay on this site are advertising, and as an eBay Partner Network affiliate we earn from qualifying purchases.
1,934 live listings   78 cards   7 players   1739 confirmed sales  updated 8 min ago

Willie Mays

157Live listings
4Cards tracked

What has sold

41 sold at a known price, $891.50 to $60,000.00, middle $3,995.00. 28 accepted offers where eBay never published the figure, at or below $40,000.00.
DateWhatCertifiedPriceConfidence
2026-11-13Toppssee this market
1953 TOPPS #244 WILLIE MAYS PSA 3
PSA 3$3,695.00HIGH
2026-11-12Toppssee this market
1952 TOPPS #261 WILLIE MAYS PSA 4
PSA 4≤ $12,999.00LOW
2026-11-11Toppssee this market
1953 Topps #244 Willie Mays New York Giants HOF PSA 3 VG
PSA 3$2,758.45HIGH
2026-11-10Toppssee this market
1953 Topps Willie Mays #244 Graded PSA 1.5
PSA 1.5≤ $2,000.00LOW
2026-11-09Toppssee this market
1952 Topps - Semi-High # Willie Mays #261 SGC 4.5
SGC 4.5$9,500.00HIGH
2026-11-03Toppssee this market
SGC 1 1952 Topps Willie Mays #261 New York Giants Graded Vintage Baseball Card
SGC 1$2,850.00HIGH
2026-11-01Toppssee this market
SGC 1 1952 Topps Willie Mays #261 New York Giants Graded Vintage Baseball Card
SGC 1$3,999.95HIGH
2026-11-01Bowmansee this market
1951 BOWMAN #305 WILLIE MAYS ROOKIE RC PSA 5
PSA 5≤ $20,001.00LOW
2026-10-30Toppssee this market
1953 Topps Set-Break #244 Willie Mays PSA 4 VG-EX
PSA 4$3,708.00HIGH
2026-10-30Toppssee this market
1952 Topps Set-Break #261 Willie Mays PSA 1 PR
PSA 1$3,675.00HIGH
2026-10-26Bowmansee this market
1952 BOWMAN #218 WILLIE MAYS GIANTS HOF PSA 2
PSA 2$1,750.00HIGH
2026-10-26Toppssee this market
1953 TOPPS #244 WILLIE MAYS PSA 2
PSA 2≤ $2,499.00LOW
2026-10-26Toppssee this market
ORIGINAL 1952 TOPPS BASEBALL #261 WILLIE MAYS NEW YORK GIANTS SGC 1 POOR
SGC 1$2,250.00HIGH
2026-10-22Bowmansee this market
1952 Bowman #218 Willie Mays New York Giants HOF PSA 4.5 " ICONIC CARD "
PSA 4.5$4,500.00HIGH
2026-10-21Bowmansee this market
1951 Bowman Willie Mays Rc #305 PSA 2.5 - POP 95
PSA 2.5≤ $12,999.99LOW
2026-10-20Bowmansee this market
1951 BOWMAN #305 WILLIE MAYS ROOKIE RC PSA 6
PSA 6≤ $40,000.00LOW
2026-10-18Toppssee this market
1952 Topps Willie Mays #261 SGC 7
SGC 7≤ $38,850.00LOW
2026-10-17Toppssee this market
1952 Topps Willie Mays New York Giants #261 Semi-High PSA 1 Cert 171102617
PSA 1$2,300.00HIGH
2026-10-17Toppssee this market
1952 Topps Willie Mays #261 PSA 1 PR Semi-High New York Giants 171102616
PSA 1$2,503.00HIGH
2026-10-16Bowmansee this market
1951 Bowman Willie Mays PSA 1
PSA 1$4,190.00HIGH
2026-10-16Toppssee this market
1952 Topps Set-Break #261 Willie Mays PSA 4 VG-EX
PSA 4$10,300.00HIGH
2026-10-16Bowmansee this market
1951 Bowman Baseball WILLIE MAYS #305 RC Rookie Giants Hof Vintage PSA 2 S1083
PSA 2$7,655.00HIGH
2026-10-15Bowmansee this market
1952 BOWMAN #218 WILLIE MAYS PSA 1
PSA 1$891.50HIGH
2026-10-15Bowmansee this market
WILLIE MAYS PSA 2 1951 BOWMAN BASEBALL #305 ROOKIE RC GIANTS 2325
PSA 2$8,950.00HIGH
2026-10-15Toppssee this market
1952 Topps Willie Mays #261 PSA 5 cheapest psa 5 on ebay
PSA 5≤ $15,700.00LOW

A price shown with ≤ was an accepted best offer: eBay does not publish what was actually paid, so the asking price is a ceiling rather than a figure.

By season

1951 Bowman

#305 sole 1951 card for Mays; PSA CardFacts and the 1951 Bowman checklist39 listed
GradeListedCheapestMiddle
PSA 91$24.00—
PSA 8 MC1$32,500.00—
PSA 81$33,900.00—
PSA 8 OC2$58,000.00—view
PSA 74$78,000.00$95,411.00view
PSA 7 MC1$24,999.99—
PSA 7 OC1$30,000.00—
PSA 6.51$56,357.00—
PSA 63$40,000.00$40,677.00view
PSA 52$25,000.00—view
SGC 51$26,500.00—
BVG 51$15,250.00—
PSA 4.51$18,489.00—
PSA 43$14,788.88$15,640.00view
SGC 41$11,999.99—view
PSA 3.51$12,696.99—view
PSA 3 MC1$11,000.00—
PSA 34$11,550.00$13,050.00view
PSA 2.52$11,000.00—view
PSA 22$10,997.00—view
SGC 1.51$13,995.00—
PSA 1.52$5,699.00—view
PSA 1 MC1$7,599.00—
PSA 11$6,999.00—view

1952 Bowman

#218 from the 1952 Bowman checklist; Mays is his only card in the set21 listed
GradeListedCheapestMiddle
PSA 7 OC1$4,750.00—
PSA 62$6,499.00—view
PSA 53$3,025.00$5,399.00view
PSA 42$3,250.00—view
SGC 32$2,700.00—view
PSA 31$2,499.99—view
PSA 21$2,699.00—view
PSA 2 MK1$1,395.00—
PSA 1.53$1,299.99$1,430.00view
PSA 14$950.00$1,045.97view
PSA No numeric grade1$1,500.00—

1952 Topps

#261 1952 Topps is one card per player, no subsets57 listed
GradeListedCheapestMiddle
PSA 71$65,317.00—view
PSA 55$17,999.99$18,277.00view
PSA 5 MC1$9,999.99—
BVG 51$19,899.00—
PSA 4.53$18,000.00$18,750.00view
SGC 4.51$11,000.00—view
BVG 4.51$11,499.99—
PSA 45$10,500.00$11,999.00view
BVG 3.51$9,900.00—
PSA 3.52$10,995.00—view
PSA 33$9,150.00$16,000.00view
SGC 31$10,499.00—
BVG 22$3,358.25—view
SGC 23$5,300.00$5,400.00view
PSA 26$6,000.00$7,598.49view
PSA 2 MC1$4,399.99—
PSA 2 MK1$5,999.00—
SGC 1.51$4,999.99—
BVG 1.51$3,800.00—
PSA 111$2,350.00$3,519.99view
PSA 1 MC1$3,250.00—
PSA 1 MK1$2,910.00—
SGC 11$3,416.39—view
PSA No numeric grade2$6,000.00—view
SGC No numeric grade1$2,499.99—

1953 Topps

#244 1953 Topps is a 274-card base set, one card per player, no subsets40 listed
GradeListedCheapestMiddle
SGC 81$125,000.00—
BVG 61$6,615.00—
SGC 51$8,800.00—
PSA 52$6,975.00—view
PSA 4.52$5,400.00—view
BVG 41$3,200.00—
PSA 48$3,900.00$4,987.50view
SGC 42$4,960.00—view
PSA 3.52$5,857.00—view
BGS 31$3,950.00—
PSA 34$4,244.90$4,757.50view
SGC 31$3,850.00—
BVG 31$4,499.99—
PSA 2.52$3,196.96—view
PSA 23$2,200.00$3,137.00view
SGC 22$2,500.00—view
PSA 2 MK1$1,900.00—
PSA 1.52$2,150.00—view
SGC 11$1,250.00—view
PSA 12$2,257.00—view