Advertising disclosure: EarlyCardIndex is a participant in the eBay Partner Network. Links to eBay on this site are advertising, and as an eBay Partner Network affiliate we earn from qualifying purchases.
1,934 live listings   78 cards   7 players   1739 confirmed sales  updated 8 min ago

Mickey Mantle

222Live listings
6Cards tracked

What has sold

72 sold at a known price, $148.57 to $88,740.00, middle $4,422.49. 52 accepted offers where eBay never published the figure, at or below $199,999.99.
DateWhatCertifiedPriceConfidence
2026-11-20Bowmansee this market
1953 Bowman Color #59 Mickey Mantle SGC 4 VG-EX Iconic Clean Sharp
SGC 4≤ $4,299.00LOW
2026-11-18Toppssee this market
1953 Topps 82 Mickey Mantle PSA 1 MBA Bronze 92056319
PSA 1$2,900.00HIGH
2026-11-17Toppssee this market
1953 Topps - Mickey Mantle #82 PSA 5 MBA Gold Centered
PSA 5≤ $31,995.00LOW
2026-11-17Toppssee this market
1953 Topps #82 Mickey Mantle Psa 3 New Grade Centered MBA Gold Top 5% Beauty
PSA 3$15,495.00HIGH
2026-11-16Bowmansee this market
1953 Bowman Color Set-Break # 44 Bauer, Berra, Mantle SGC 2.5 GD+
SGC 2.5$399.00HIGH
2026-11-12Bowmansee this market
1953 Bowman Color Mickey Mantle #59 New York Yankees SGC 2
SGC 2$2,000.00HIGH
2026-11-09Toppssee this market
1953 TOPPS #82 MICKEY MANTLE YANKEES HOF PSA 1
PSA 1$3,521.00HIGH
2026-11-09Bowmansee this market
1953 Bowman Color Mickey Mantle #59 Yankees CGC 1
CGC 1≤ $949.00LOW
2026-11-08Bowmansee this market
1953 Bowman Color #44 Yogi Berra Hank Bauer Mickey Mantle PSA 7 New York Yankees
PSA 7$1,999.99HIGH
2026-11-05Bowmansee this market
1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle #253 Rookie RC CGC 4.5 VG/EX+ Great Eye Appeal
CGC 4.5$39,995.00HIGH
2026-11-04Bowmansee this market
1952 Bowman #101 Mickey Mantle SGC 1 Nice Eye Appeal
SGC 1$3,699.99HIGH
2026-11-02Bowmansee this market
MICKEY MANTLE 1952 BOWMAN PSA 1 POOR *FRESHLY GRADED
PSA 1$2,600.00HIGH
2026-11-02Bowmansee this market
1953 BOWMAN COLOR BASEBALL #59 MICKEY MANTLE PSA 7 NM HOF YANKEES
PSA 7≤ $12,777.77LOW
2026-11-01Bowmansee this market
1953 Bowman Color - Mickey Mantle #59 PSA 1
PSA 1≤ $2,777.77LOW
2026-11-01Bowmansee this market
1952 Bowman #101 Mickey Mantle SGC 2.5 GD+. New York Yankees HOF. Great Color
SGC 2.5$5,200.00HIGH
2026-10-31Toppssee this market
MICKEY MANTLE 1953 TOPPS BASEBALL #82 NEW YORK YANKEES PSA 4.5 Q6995
PSA 4.5$11,999.99HIGH
2026-10-31Bowmansee this market
1951 Bowman #253 Mickey Mantle Rookie RC PSA 5 Well Centered, Nice Registration
PSA 5$64,995.00HIGH
2026-10-30Bowmansee this market
1951 BOWMAN #253 MICKEY MANTLE ROOKIE RC PSA 5
PSA 5≤ $57,500.00LOW
2026-10-28Bowmansee this market
1951 BOWMAN #253 MICKEY MANTLE ROOKIE RC PSA 2
PSA 2≤ $25,000.00LOW
2026-10-27Toppssee this market
1953 Topps #82 Mickey Mantle HOF PSA 4.5 beautiful centering super clean look !!
PSA 4.5≤ $12,500.00LOW
2026-10-26Bowmansee this market
1951 Bowman MICKEY MANTLE RC Rookie #253 NEW YORK YANKEES HoF PSA 2 Good INSANE!
PSA 2$21,544.00HIGH
2026-10-26Toppssee this market
1952 TOPPS #311 MICKEY MANTLE YANKEES HOF PSA 1
PSA 1$88,740.00HIGH
2026-10-25Toppssee this market
1953 TOPPS MICKEY MANTLE #82 PSA 2 RECENTLY GRADED, LOOKS NICER
PSA 2$7,195.00HIGH
2026-10-24Toppssee this market
1953 Topps MICKEY MANTLE Baseball Card #82 PSA 2 (MK)
PSA 2$5,800.00HIGH
2026-10-24Toppssee this market
1953 Topps Set-Break # 82 Mickey Mantle PSA 2.5 GOOD+
PSA 2.5≤ $7,300.00LOW

A price shown with ≤ was an accepted best offer: eBay does not publish what was actually paid, so the asking price is a ceiling rather than a figure.

By season

1951 Bowman

#253 his actual rookie, and the cheaper of the two38 listed
GradeListedCheapestMiddle
PSA 8 OC1$150,000.00—view
PSA 61$102,388.88—
BVG 5.51$75,000.00—
PSA 51$80,000.00—view
PSA 5 MC1$33,600.00—
PSA 4.52$48,307.00—view
BVG 4.51$40,950.00—
SGC 4.51$52,500.00—
SGC 41$34,999.99—
PSA 4 MC1$34,750.00—
PSA 44$43,197.00$49,999.99view
SGC 3.51$36,750.00—
BVG 3.51$28,350.00—
PSA 36$33,505.00$37,800.00view
PSA 2.52$33,600.00—view
CGC 21$24,150.00—
PSA 21$28,500.00—view
PSA 1.5 MC1$15,999.99—
PSA 14$15,999.00$18,500.00view
PSA 1 MK1$13,248.88—
PSA 1 MC2$15,999.99—view
PSA No numeric grade3$11,999.99$14,995.00view

1952 Bowman

#101 his only 1952 Bowman card, per two independent Mantle checklists53 listed
GradeListedCheapestMiddle
BVG 7.51$49,999.00—
SGC 71$50,000.00—
PSA 71$100,000.00—
PSA 6.51$27,777.77—
SGC 61$15,014.95—
PSA 62$24,950.00—view
PSA 54$13,800.00$15,178.50view
PSA 4.51$15,495.00—
SGC 42$8,500.00—view
PSA 44$10,000.00$12,890.99view
PSA 3.51$8,200.00—
PSA 34$7,999.99$8,647.49view
SGC 32$7,999.00—view
SGC 2.53$4,952.00$5,299.99view
PSA 2.55$5,579.99$6,999.99view
PSA 25$4,900.00$7,299.99view
PSA 1.54$3,500.00$4,624.99view
SGC 1.51$4,299.99—
PSA 12$3,206.00—view
SGC 12$4,999.99—view
SGC No numeric grade4$1,879.99$2,500.00view
PSA No numeric grade2$3,199.99—view

1952 Topps

#311 his only 1952 Topps card; the set is one per player28 listed
GradeListedCheapestMiddle
PSA 62$630,000.00—view
PSA 5.51$525,000.00—
PSA 51$600,000.00—
BGS 51$524,999.99—
PSA 4.52$383,250.00—view
PSA 42$246,750.00—view
PSA 3.52$500,000.00—view
PSA 32$224,999.99—view
SGC 32$183,750.00—view
PSA 2.51$149,999.99—
PSA 21$134,400.00—
PSA 1.5 MK1$89,250.00—
PSA 1.51$135,000.00—
SGC 12$65,100.00—view
PSA 14$52,999.99$88,050.00view
PSA No numeric grade2$49,999.99—view
SGC No numeric grade1$74,999.00—

1953 Bowman

#44 Mantle with Berra and Bauer, 1953 Bowman Color22 listed
GradeListedCheapestMiddle
PSA 81$5,585.00—
PSA 62$1,375.00—view
BVG 61$990.00—view
BVG 51$1,131.10—
SGC 51$799.95—view
PSA 52$995.00—view
BGS 41$855.00—
PSA 43$699.99$750.00view
PSA 34$430.00$663.50view
PSA 1.51$326.80—view
SGC 12$200.00—view
PSA 1 MC1$210.00—
PSA 11$255.00—view
CGC 11$339.99—
#59 1953 Bowman Color, his solo card22 listed
GradeListedCheapestMiddle
PSA 7.51$17,995.00—
SGC 7.51$22,200.00—
PSA 71$12,138.88—view
PSA 54$6,399.99$7,454.44view
SGC 51$7,900.00—view
PSA 4.51$5,500.00—
PSA 42$6,400.00—view
PSA 3.51$4,800.00—view
PSA 31$3,880.00—view
SGC 2.53$3,200.00$3,300.00view
PSA 21$2,749.99—view
PSA 1.52$2,495.00—view
SGC 1.51$2,205.00—
PSA 11$1,799.99—view
SGC 11$1,278.88—view

1953 Topps

#82 his only 1953 Topps card; the set is one per player59 listed
GradeListedCheapestMiddle
PSA 8 OC1$27,500.00—
PSA 73$54,995.00$73,999.00view
PSA 62$22,999.95—view
PSA 56$19,999.95$21,332.33view
PSA 5 MC1$8,950.00—
PSA 4.52$14,917.00—view
PSA 43$10,500.00$12,138.88view
PSA 3.51$9,200.00—
PSA 32$8,999.99—view
PSA 2.51$8,995.00—view
PSA 29$7,388.88$8,799.99view
PSA 1.57$5,250.00$6,500.00view
PSA 116$3,275.00$4,300.00view
PSA 1 MC1$3,256.00—
PSA 1 MK1$3,299.99—view
PSA No numeric grade3$2,995.00$3,675.00view